A case of first impression is a case or controversy over an interpretation of law never before reported or decided by that court. There is no binding authority in a case of first impression. Categories: Stub | Software engineering | Data management ... Look up Controversy in Wiktionary, the free dictionary A controversy is a contentious dispute, a disagreement in opinions over which parties are actively arguing. ... Corruption Jurisprudence Philosophy of law Law (principle) List of legal abbreviations Legal code Intent Letter versus Spirit Natural Justice Natural law Religious law Witness intimidation Legal research External links Wikibooks Wikiversity has more about this subject: School of Law Look up law in Wiktionary, the free dictionary Law, Legal Definitions... In law, a reporter is a series of books which contain court opinions. ... A court is an official, public forum which a public power establishes by lawful authority to adjudicate disputes, and to dispense civil, labour, administrative and criminal justice under the law. ...
A case of first impression may be a case of first impression in only a particular jurisdiction. In that situation, courts will look to holdings of other jurisdictions for persuasive authority. In law, jurisdiction refers to the aspect of a any unique legal authority as being localized within boundaries. ... Precedent is the principle in law of using the past in order to assist in current interpretation and decision-making. ...
Where no persuasive authority exists, a judge will look to legal analogies, legal commentary, legal briefs of the parties, and his or her own legal logic. An analogy is a comparison between two different things, in order to highlight some form of similarity. ... It has been suggested that this article or section be merged with College logic. ...
In some situations, a case of first impression may exist in a jurisdiction until a reported appellate court decision is rendered. An appellate court is a court that hears cases in which a lower court -- either a trial court or a lower-level appellate court — has already made some decision, which at least one party to the action wants to challenge based upon some legal grounds that are allowed to be...
Basing its decision on federal caselaw, the court determined that there is no evidence that the misconduct of the male workers was of "comparable seriousness" to that of the female workers.
Dallas solo John Wall, who represents plaintiffs in employment discrimination cases but is not involved in Monarrez, says the state Supreme Court found as a matter of fact that the infractions of the female employees were less severe than those of the male employees, even though the record suggests there was evidence to the contrary.
Monarrez and Rodriguez alleged in their brief to the Supreme Court that at least some female employees of the district's transportation department punched time cards for other female employees, and that one female employee frequently "punched in" her daughter when the daughter was not present.
In a case of firstimpression there is no mandatory precedent.
Persuasive precedent or advisory precedent are cases which a court may use but is not required to follow in deciding its cases.
In a case of firstimpression, courts often rely on persuasive precedent from courts in other jurisdictions that have previously dealt with similar issues.
Feeds |
Contact