NationMaster - Encyclopedia: Fred A. Leuchter

Frederick A. (Fred) Leuchter, Jr. (born 1943) is an American execution technician who became controversial and then destitute after testifying in defense of Holocaust revisionist Ernst Zündel. He claims to have improved the electric chair to make it more humane, designed a lethal injection machine, and he claims to have acted as a consultant about gallows and gas chambers, although a number of states he claims to have acted as a consultant for have denied such a relationship ever existed. His machines have been used by several U.S. states. His study for Zündel's trial is referred to as the Leuchter Report and are often regarded as a scientific touchstone of Holocaust revisionism. A documentary, entitled Mr. Death: the Rise and Fall of Fred A. Leuchter, Jr. was released by Errol Morris in 1999. 1943 (MCMXLIII) is a common year starting on Friday. ... In law and in religion, testimony is a solemn attestation as to the truth of a matter. ... Richard Harwoods Did Six Million Really Die? Holocaust denial is the claim that the mainstream historical version of the Holocaust is either highly exaggerated or completely falsified. ... ZÃ¼ndel Ernst Christof Friedrich ZÃ¼ndel (sometimes spelled Zundel or Zuendel) (born April 24, 1939 in Bad Wildbad) is a German Holocaust denier and pamphleteer who was jailed several times for publishing hate literature. ... The first electric chair, which was used to execute William Kemmler in 1890 The electric chair is a device used in 11 states in the United States for execution of criminals convicted of capital crimes. ... Lethal injection involves injecting a person with fatal doses of drugs to cause death. ... These gallows in Tombstone Courthouse State Historic Park are maintained by Arizona State Parks. ... The gas chamber once used at San Quentin State Prison in California for the purpose of capital punishment. ... A state of the United States (U.S. state) is any one of the fifty states, four of which officially favor the term commonwealth which, along with the District of Columbia, form the United States of America. ... Errol Morris Errol Morris (born February 5, 1948) is an American Academy Award winning documentary film director. ... 1999 (MCMXCIX) was a common year starting on Friday, and was designated the International Year of Older Persons by the United Nations. ...

Fred Leuchter Associates

Leuchter spent much of his life offering services to several states to help them maintain, improve, document, and ascertain their equipment for administration of capital punishment, via his firm, Fred Leuchter Associates. His initial work was with electric chairs, starting in Tennessee. Leuchter's broader claims are that his work in this area is "humanitarian," providing greater respect for both guards and those to be executed. He later stated that he supported "capital punishment, not capital torture." He also claims that he offered his services at considerable economy: off-the-shelf parts, labor, and a 20% profit. By his own account, consultation between state government agencies spread his reputation from Tennessee to other states, and further assignments followed. According to the same account, these agencies did not appear concerned with tasking Leuchter with working on execution systems with which he had no previous experience, and it was in this manner that Leuchter's proposal for a lethal injection system was first accepted by New Jersey. // Capital punishment, or the death penalty, is the governmental use of execution as punishment for a crime often called a capital offense or a capital crime. ... Official language(s) English Capital Nashville Largest city Memphis Area - Total - Width - Length - % water - Latitude - Longitude Ranked 36th 109,247 kmÂ² 195 km 710 km 2. ... Humanitarianism is the view that all people should be treated with the respect and dignity they deserve as human beings, and that advancing the well-being of humanity is a noble goal. ... Official language(s) None defined, English de facto Capital Trenton Largest city Newark Area - Total - Width - Length - % water - Latitude - Longitude Ranked 47th 22,608 kmÂ² 110 km 240 km 14. ...

An October 13, 1990, New York Times article, which described him as "The nation’s leading adviser on capital punishment", quoted an expert anesthesiologist on Leuchter's lethal injection machine saying "His injection system would render an inmate incapable of screaming about the 'extreme pain in the form of a severe burning sensation' caused by... potassium chloride." Newsweek 's October 22, 1990 issue published a claim by Alabama Assistant Attorney General Ed Carnes calling Leuchter's views on the gas chamber "unorthodox" and alleging that "Leuchter was running a death row shakedown scheme: if a state didn't purchase Leuchter's services, he would testify at the last minute for the condemned man that the state's death chamber might malfunction." October 13 is the 286th day of the year (287th in leap years). ... This article is about the year. ... The New York Times is an internationally known daily newspaper published in New York City and distributed in the United States and many other nations worldwide. ... The Newsweek logo Newsweek is a weekly news magazine published in New York City and distributed throughout the United States and internationally. ... October 22 is the 295th day of the year (296th in leap years) in the Gregorian Calendar, with 70 days remaining. ... This article is about the year. ... In most common law jurisdictions, the Attorney General is the main legal adviser to the government, and in some jurisdictions may in addition have executive responsibility for law enforcement or responsibility for public prosecutions. ...

The Associated Press quoted Carnes claiming that Leuchter made 'money on both sides of the fence.' (Associated Press, October 24, 1990). In his memorandum to death penalty states, Carnes observed that in Florida and Virginia the federal courts had rejected Leuchter's testimony as unreliable. The court in Florida had found that Leuchter had 'misquoted the statements' contained in an important affidavit and had 'inaccurately surmised' a crucial premise of his conclusion. In Virginia, Leuchter provided a death-row inmate's attorney with an affidavit claiming the electric chair would fail. The Virginia court decided the credibility of Leuchter's affidavit was limited because Leuchter was "the refused contractor who bid to replace the electrodes in the Virginia chair. (Newsweek, October 22, 1990, pg. 22) (In the film Mr. Death, Leuchter, stating that electrocution would be his choice if he were compelled to select the means of his own execution, gives Florida, Alabama, and Virginia as the names of three states where he would not want to be electrocuted.) Associated Press logo The Associated Press, or AP, is an American news agency, the worlds largest such organization. ...

The investigation

Because of his background and on the recommendation of Robert Faurisson (Faurisson had become convinced several years previously that comparison to the use of the gas chamber in American capital punishment was the most meaningful basis for understanding various technical issues involved in the Nazi gas chambers), he was asked by Ernst Zündel, who was being tried in Canada for publishing works of Holocaust denial, to investigate and testify as an expert witness at his trial. Leuchter traveled to Auschwitz and Birkenau to examine the structures identified as gas chambers, and concluded that they could not have been used for mass murder. He published his findings as The Leuchter Report, which the court accepted only as evidentiary display and not as direct evidence; Leuchter was therefore required to explicate it and testify to the veracity of his findings under oath in the trial. His report was widely republished and translated by various revisionist organisations, and he has since lectured on it and his subsequent experiences. Protests were organized in response. Leuchter's defenders say these protests destroyed his career and his life. Robert Faurisson Robert Faurisson (born January 25, 1929) is a French holocaust-denier who generated controversy over various articles he published in the Journal of Historical Review and elsewhere, as well as various letters he has sent in to French newspapers (especially Le Monde) over the years which denied the... // Capital punishment, or the death penalty, is the governmental use of execution as punishment for a crime often called a capital offense or a capital crime. ... ZÃ¼ndel Ernst Christof Friedrich ZÃ¼ndel (sometimes spelled Zundel or Zuendel) (born April 24, 1939 in Bad Wildbad) is a German Holocaust denier and pamphleteer who was jailed several times for publishing hate literature. ... Richard Harwoods Did Six Million Really Die? Holocaust denial is the claim that the mainstream historical version of the Holocaust is either highly exaggerated or completely falsified. ... Auschwitz, in English, commonly refers to the Auschwitz concentration camp complex built near the town of Oświęcim, by Nazi Germany during World War II. Rarely, it may refer to the Polish town of Oświęcim (called by the Germans Auschwitz) itself. ... Birkenau may mean the following: the municipality Birkenau in Hesse, see Birkenau, Hesse the German spelling of the Polish Brzezinka the death camp and part of the concentration camp Auschwitz located near Brzezinka, see Auschwitz concentration camp This is a disambiguation page — a navigational aid which lists other pages that... The gas chamber once used at San Quentin State Prison in California for the purpose of capital punishment. ...

Leuchter traveled to several sites of structures identified as gas chambers, where he collected samples from walls, ceilings and floors. He took copious notes about the floor plans and layout, and all of his actions were videotaped by a cameraman. (Leuchter, who had been married for about one month before the trip, told his wife that the trip to Auschwitz-Birkenau was their honeymoon.) Leuchter then brought the samples back to Boston, where he presented them to Alpha Analytical Laboratories, a top laboratory, for testing. Leuchter told Alpha only that the samples were to be used as evidence in a court case about an industrial accident. The lab tested them for exposure to cyanide and concluded that no traces of it could be found. When asked, lab manager James Roth swore under oath to the results at the trial. A cyanide is any chemical compound that contains the cyano group Câ‰¡N, with the carbon atom triple-bonded to the nitrogen atom. ...

Only after he got off the stand did Roth learn what the trial was about. He later said that cyanide could only penetrate the stone masonry of the gas chambers to the depth of one-tenth of a human hair. However, Roth had pulverized the samples, thus severely diluting them (In an interview for Morris's film, Roth states that cyanide would form an extremely fine layer on the walls and that the fragments he tested were not adequately identified as to what faces Leuchter thought had been exposed, so the samples were pulverised with no respect for isolating these surfaces; Roth offers the analogy that the test were like looking at timbers when one needed to be looking at paint).

Leuchter did not examine the walls of the gas chambers until fifty years after they had been used; his critics note that it would have been virtually impossible to discover any cyanide at all using his method. In fact, tests conducted on ventilation grates immediately after the end of the war showed substantial amounts of cyanide. Leuchter was unaware that part of the camp and chambers were reconstructed, so he had no way of knowing if the bricks he was scraping were actually part of the original gas chamber.

Leuchter also asserted that the necessary ventilation systems and other pieces simply would not fit. Documents from the period show that the gas chambers in fact had powerful ventilators capable of clearing the gas chambers in minutes. When challenged in court, Leuchter said he was unaware of those documents. The chambers were demolished by the Nazis when they abandoned Auschwitz and the facilities Leuchter examined were, in fact, reconstructions. Leuchter has no training or expertise in the designing of gas chambers.

Many of Leuchter's conclusions are based on the assumption that it takes 20 to 30 hours to air a room disinfected with Zyklon-B; since far lower concentrations are required when gassing people it actually takes 20 to 30 minutes to air out the room and the forced ventilation systems used are more than adequate to allow the gas chambers to be operated safely. When questioned in court, Leuchter admitted he had not seen a document by the Waffen SS Commandant for construction issued when the gas chambers were constructed which estimated they had a 24 hour capacity of 4756 people, more than 30 times Leuchter's estimate of 156. Zyklon B Canister atop diatomaceous earth substrate. ...

During the trial, Leuchter also made claims that it would be dangerous to house the furnaces for cremating the victims in the same building in which the gas chambers were located, because the "gas might explode" The gas only explodes at a minimal concentration of 56,000 PPM, about 200 times more than the lethal concentration. Leuchter also testified that it was impossible to kill six million people at Auschwitz (six million is the estimate commonly given for all Jews killed during the Holocaust, not the estimated number of those gassed at Auschwitz.) Further in regards to Leuchter's estimates on the numbers who could be killed by gas chambers at Auschwitz: Selection at the Auschwitz ramp in 1944, where the German Nazis chose whom to kill immediately and whom to use as slave labor or for medical experimentation, such as those of the infamous Dr. Josef Mengele. ...

He also asserts that the traces of cyanide compounds in the remains of the gas chambers in Auschwitz is less than in the "delousing chambers" in which clothes were deloused (using the same gas, hydrogen cyanide). However, according to toxicologists it takes a much higher concentration of the gas to kill lice and bugs (16,000 parts per million) than to kill humans and other warm blooded creatures (300 PPM). Further, killing lice requires an exposure time of many hours while only minutes are needed for people.

Leuchter denies any desire to disprove the Holocaust, and does not deny the Holocaust happened, but claims he is convinced that the structures he saw were not gas chambers. He claims he conducted the investigation and testified about it because he believed in freedom of speech and freedom of thought and felt that people should be allowed to publish their views, however misguided and that he believes every man deserves a fair trial (Zündel was facing 25 years in prison if he lost), and he was the only expert competent to provide the key testimony. However, critics argue that Leuchter had a profitable career as an "expert witness" for hire who would say whatever his contractor wanted him to say and, according to trial testimony, Zündel paid Leuchter $35,000 for his report. A public demonstration Freedom of speech is often regarded as an integral concept in modern liberal democracies, where it is understood to outlaw censorship. ... Freedom of thought (also called freedom of conscience) is the freedom of an individual to hold a viewpoint, or thought, regardless of anyone elses view. ...

Aftermath

Protests were organized outside the court house in Canada, and near Leuchter's home in Malden, Massachusetts. However, despite the bad publicity Leuchter remained active until 1990, when his lack of qualifications to practice were exposed. In the late 1980s, following the Ernst Zündel trial, he was featured in both the Atlantic Monthly and Prime Time Live in items on capital punishment, neither of which mentioned his association with Zundel. Also following his involvement in the Zündel trial, Leuchter began giving lectures to Holocaust revisionist groups such as the Institute for Historical Review about his research and continued belief in the conclusions to which he testified in the trial. A speech to the Eleventh IHR Conference in October, 1992, included the following remark: Malden is a city located in Middlesex County, Massachusetts. ... ZÃ¼ndel Ernst Christof Friedrich ZÃ¼ndel (sometimes spelled Zundel or Zuendel) (born April 24, 1939 in Bad Wildbad) is a German Holocaust denier and pamphleteer who was jailed several times for publishing hate literature. ... The Atlantic Monthly (also known as The Atlantic) is an American literary/cultural magazine that was founded in November 1857. ... PrimeTime is a television newsmagazine from ABC News. ... Richard Harwoods Did Six Million Really Die? Holocaust denial is the claim that the mainstream historical version of the Holocaust is either highly exaggerated or completely falsified. ... The Institute for Historical Review (IHR), founded in 1978, is a leading Holocaust denial organization. ... 1992 (MCMXCII) was a leap year starting on Wednesday. ...

In October 1990, the state of Massachusetts brought criminal charges against Leuchter for representing himself as an engineer without a license. Leuchter says he was a victim of selective prosecution, since only 10% of engineers are actually licensed. Leuchter not only lacks an engineering licence but hasn't an engineering degree or other professional certification or recognised credential — his only education consists of a BA in history, which he completed in 1964. He admits to having no formal training in toxicology, biology or chemistry. Additionally, while Leuchter had some experience with electric chairs and lethal injection systems it was discovered that his claims of expertise in the area of gas chambers was a fabrication and he had no experience with them. This article is about the year. ... In jurisprudence, selective prosecution is a procedural defense via which a defendant may argue that they should not be held criminally liable for breaking the law, as the criminal justice system discriminated against them by choosing to prosecute. ... For the Nintendo 64 emulator, see 1964 (Emulator). ... Toxicology (from the Greek words toxicon and logos) is the study of the adverse effects of chemicals on living organisms. ... Biology is a branch of science, dealing with the study of life. ... Multicolored chemicals are frequent hallmarks of chemistry. ... The first electric chair, which was used to execute William Kemmler in 1890 The electric chair is a device used in 11 states in the United States for execution of criminals convicted of capital crimes. ... Lethal injection involves injecting a person with fatal doses of drugs to cause death. ...

When he tried to sell parts of a lethal injection machine and other inventory from Fred Leuchter Associates, much of it items pending work for various states who refused to pay him for previously contracted or agreed work, he was again charged (Leuchter claims that the Massachusetts Attourney General had to explain that the sale of the offered equipment was not, in fact, illegal); his wife divorced him in this same period. The issues surrounding the equipment sale were covered in Boston area newspapers. Leutcher further claimed that states (he has named Delaware and its Deputy Attorney General, Fred Silverman) refused to do business with him and reneged on existing agreements not because of his lack of qualification but because of his involvement in the Zündel trial.

Now without a job or wife, he received an offer to come out to California, but the company he went to work for ran out of money, leaving Leuchter stranded. David Irving, speaking several years before losing his libel lawsuit against Deborah Lipstadt and the ruin of his own reputation before a British court, expressed surprise that Leuchter did not commit suicide as a result of his destitution. Irving has called Leuchter a "simpleton" even as he has said that Leuchter's report convinced him that the received history Holocaust is a lie (Lipstadt's counsel in the libel trial cited Irving's contemporaneous statements to this effect in his opening statement). Official language(s) English Capital Sacramento Largest city Los Angeles Area - Total - Width - Length - % water - Latitude - Longitude Ranked 3rd 158,302 sq mi 410,000 kmÂ² 250 miles 402. ... David Irving, 2003 David John Cawdell Irving (born March 24, 1938) is the British author of several best-selling books about the military history of World War II. He is widely known as a Holocaust denier, although he has recently appeared to change his position, saying that [t]he Nazis... Lipstadts book: Denying The Holocaust Deborah Lipstadt is an American historian and author of the book Denying the Holocaust. ...

Leuchter was arrested in and shortly thereafter deported from the United Kingdom in November 1991. He had been banned from entering the country by the Home Office and his entry and presence in the country was therefore considered illegal. Leuchter claimed that United States consulate personnel effectively refused him aid. He had been interrupted while giving an invited speech at Irving's instigation; his talk followed immediately one by Faurisson. The account of this incident was given in the same speech from which the previous quoted block was taken. Leuchter has also referenced all the adversities to that date following his appearance in the Zündel trial, attributing them to a larger Jewish conspiracy against him, directed by Beate Klarsfeld and her Paris-based foundation. 1991 (MCMXCI) was a common year starting on Tuesday of the Gregorian calendar. ... The modern concept of Small Office and Home Office or SoHo , or Small or Home Office deals with the category of business which can be from 1 to 10 workers. ... Serge (born September 17, 1935 in Bucharest, Romania) and Beate (born February 13, 1939 in Berlin, Germany) Klarsfeld are called Nazi hunters for bringing Klaus Barbie and others to justice. ... , The Eiffel Tower, the tallest structure in Paris, is an international symbol of the city. ...

Repetition of Leuchter's examination

In February of 1990, Professor Jan Markiewicz, Director of the Forensic Institute of Cracow, redid the analysis.[2] Markiewicz decided that the Prussian blue test was unreliable because it depended on the acidity of the environment, which was low in the purported gas chambers. Markiewicz and his team used microdiffusion techniques to test for cyanide in samples from the purported gas chambers, from delousing chambers, and from control areas elsewhere within Auschwitz. The control samples tested negative, while cyanide residue was found in both the delousing chambers and the purported gas chambers. The amount of cyanide found had a great variability (possibly due to 50 years of exposure to the elements to varying degrees[3]), but even so, the categorical results were that cyanide was found where expected, i.e. the delousing chambers, and not found where not expected, i.e. the control samples. Look up February in Wiktionary, the free dictionary February is the second month of the year in the Gregorian Calendar. ... This article is about the year. ... A sample of prussian blue Prussian blue (PreuÃŸisch Blau, Berliner Blau) is a dark blue pigment used in paints and formerly in blueprints. ...

Mr. Death

Leuchter is the subject of a 1999 documentary by Errol Morris, entitled Mr. Death: The Rise and Fall of Fred A. Leuchter, Jr. The film received wide acclaim. When Morris originally screened an early version of the film for a Harvard film class, he found that the students reacted by either believing Leuchter's side of the story or by condemning the film as a piece of Holocaust denial. Morris had no such intention, however, as Morris had considered it obvious that Leuchter was wrong, and that the central idea of the film was intended to be the exploration of Leuchter as a being almost completely lacking self-knowledge: 1999 (MCMXCIX) was a common year starting on Friday, and was designated the International Year of Older Persons by the United Nations. ... Errol Morris Errol Morris (born February 5, 1948) is an American Academy Award winning documentary film director. ... Harvard University is a private university in Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA, and a member of the Ivy League. ... Richard Harwoods Did Six Million Really Die? Holocaust denial is the claim that the mainstream historical version of the Holocaust is either highly exaggerated or completely falsified. ...

Thus, the "fall" of Leuchter's life is portrayed not as a result of any particular ill feelings toward the Jewish people or passionate support for revisionist history, but rather as an absurd man bumbling his way into saying and believing absurd things. Errol Morris re-edited the film to include additional interviews with people who condemn Leuchter with varying intensity. Morris felt this last step should have been unnecessary, since, to him, Leuchter was so obviously misguided in much of what he says in the film.[6]

In the course of the film Leuchter goes so far as to state frankly that he could not believe in the gas chambers because he could not himself conceive of their mechanics, although he makes it plainly evident that he knows very little of the history in which these arose. He suggests a series of options (hanging, shooting, and explosives), most of which the Nazis had in fact attempted (shootings and explosives) before determining that direct, ongoing, and extensive SS involvement would not be sufficient to the genocidal objectives they set for themselves after earlier forays into mass murder, such as Einsatzgruppen and Babi Yar. Leuchter similarly appears unaware of the T-4 Euthanasia Program and the history or science behind small-scale gassings directed by Hitler's Reich Chancellery and then the SS. In a rather direct sense, the film offers that the Holocaust is fundamentally inconceivable, if not impossible, in Leuchter's mind. SS or ss or Ss may be: The Schutzstaffel, a Nazi paramilitary force Steamship (SS) (ship prefix) The United States Secret Service A submarine not powered by nuclear energy (SS) (United States Navy designator), see SSN A Soviet/Russian surface-to-surface missile, as listed by NATO reporting name Shortstop... Einsatzgruppen (a German military term meaning mission groups, loosely translated as Task Force) were semi-military groups formed in Nazi Germany before and during World War II. These death squads belonged to the SS and followed the Wehrmacht in their attacks first on Poland and then the Soviet Union. ... The massacre at Babi Yar Babi Yar (Russian:Ð‘Ð°Ð±Ð¸Ð¹ ÑÑ€, Ukrainian:Ð‘Ð°Ð±Ð¸Ð½ ÑÑ€, Babyn Yar) is a ravine in Kiev, Ukraine, which was the site of massacres of Jews, Gypsies, and other civilians by the Nazis, with assistance from local collaborators, during World War II. // Before the massacre The Germans reached Kiev on September... This poster reads: 60,000 Reichsmark is what this person suffering from hereditary defects costs the community during his lifetime. ... (helpÂ· info) (April 20, 1889 â€“ April 30, 1945) was Chancellor of Germany from 1933 and FÃ¼hrer (Leader) of Germany from 1934 until his death. ...

Morris draws out but pursues neither Leuchter's opposition, if not aversion, to gas as a means of execution (Leuchter states his belief that it is an overly hazardous means of execution in terms of other participants) nor his imputed lack of practical experience with it. His general concern with the safety of gassing methods appear to be a stumbling block for his belief in the viability of the gas chambers, the venting process for which he believed would pose a serious threat to their operators. His critics reply:

Trivia

Robert Jan van Pelt, who appears in Mr. Death to specify some of Leuchter's scholarly failures (e.g not consulting the large documentation archive available at Auschwitz), served as the primary expert witness against David Irving in his libel trial, relating to the court the strength of the physical and documentary evidence supporting the use of that camp for gassing. That testimony was printed as The Case for Auschwitz: Evidence from the Irving Trial (ISBN 0253340160). David Irving, 2003 David John Cawdell Irving (born March 24, 1938) is the British author of several best-selling books about the military history of World War II. He is widely known as a Holocaust denier, although he has recently appeared to change his position, saying that [t]he Nazis...

References

External links

Categories: 1943 births | Capital punishment | Holocaust denial | Living people ZÃ¼ndel Ernst Christof Friedrich ZÃ¼ndel (sometimes spelled Zundel or Zuendel) (born April 24, 1939 in Bad Wildbad) is a German Holocaust denier and pamphleteer who was jailed several times for publishing hate literature. ... Barbara Kulaszka member of the Law Society of Upper Canada since 1980. ... The Institute for Historical Review (IHR), founded in 1978, is a leading Holocaust denial organization. ... The Institute for Historical Review (IHR), founded in 1978, is a leading Holocaust denial organization. ... Richard J. Green (* 1964 in Boston MA) is an American chemist known for his work against Holocaust-denial and negationism, sometimes incorrectly referred to as revisionism. ... The Holocaust History Project (THHP) is a not for profit corporation in San Antonio, Texas. ... The Nizkor (Hebrew: we will remember) Project is an ongoing Internet-based project run by Ken McVay which is dedicated to countering Holocaust revisionism. ... Errol Morris Errol Morris (born February 5, 1948) is an American Academy Award winning documentary film director. ...

Contents

Fred Leuchter Associates GA_googleFillSlot("encyclopedia_square");